Friday, May 18, 2012

Book vs. Movie - The Hunger Games


Hunger Games Movie vs. Book

Like so many others, I wanted to compare The Hunger Games book versus the movie. I agree with a colleague who said that the movie is a much better accompaniment to the book than a stand alone. Having read the book made the movie much easier to understand.

I hated the shaky cinematography at the beginning of the movie and I don’t think it added at all to the feelings evoked in the movie. I was extremely disappointed by the lack of development of the relationship between Rue and Katniss. Rue’s death is such a big part of Katniss’ development and of her desire to seek revenge on the Capitol. With the lack of this definition we are left as the audience wondering why she went to such extremes to place the flowers on Rue and why District 11 broke out into rioting.

Overall, I thought the movie did a good job using Caesar Flickerman to explain the moves and motivations explained through exposition in the book. I think even more of that would have made the movie easier for those who have not read the book. My other major disappointment was the downplaying of the violence and emotions in the Arena. While I know that the producers had to get a PG-13 rating at most and violence can lead to an R rating, I wish they had stayed more true to the book in that manner.

You might surmise that I didn’t like this movie at all. You would be wrong. I actually thought, for a movie, it was excellent (other than the whole shaky camera technique which I hated). I thought it was captivating and engaging. I thought the casting was superb. But the goal was to compare the book to the movie.


Michelle said...

Good review.
I'm following you know.
Could you please follow me back here

Thanks in advance

Jess @ The secret DMS Files of Fairday Morrow said...

As you know- I completely agree! What movie director could ever compete with my imagination? ~ Jess

Anonymous said...

You have some genuinely beneficial information composed here. Good job and keep posting good stuff.

DawnZ said...

Thanks Michelle! I just joined your blog as well. Looking forward to reading your reviews.

Jess, as you know, we agree about SO much! Thanks for always supporting and reading my blog. xxoo